As many of you know, I like to read. I like to read a lot. In fact, I probably read too much. I have way too many books. I read them so fast that I don’t even remember them half the time or take the time to savor them. But I can’t help it. Ever since I was a little kid, I have read and read and collected books and even attempted to write some of my own.
So naturally, people often ask me what my favorite book is. Unlike movies, where I have a list of like five million that at any given moment of the day could be coined “my favorite,” I used to actually have an answer for the book question. When I was in high school, a friend of mine was reading Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card. When he tried to tell me about it, it sounded completely boring and uninteresting. Something about little kids fighting off an alien invasion while sprouting a lot of philosophy and getting bullied all the time. And they like to play games at their school, apparently. But my friend INSISTED that I read it because it was going to change my life, it was so good. I was like, “Fine, whatever, I guess,” just so he would shut up and also, you know, never judge a book by it’s cover and all.
Ender’s Game was the best book I had ever read, and no description or summary or praise could have really prepared me for what I read. Chances are, you’ve heard about it, your friend’s have talked about it, often in hushed whispers and awes of amazement. I won’t get into plot details or anything, but I want to point out that the book spoke to me in a way that nothing ever had before. Above all else, it was simply about what many great books are about: learning to love yourself, regardless of who or what you are, and to not take any shit from anyone. And on top of that, OSC’s writing was phenomenal. The points he expressed, the characters he created, the unthinkable places where he took the plot leave me spellbound to this day.
Orson Scott Card quickly became my favorite author. Not just one of my favorites; my favorite. The cock of the walk. I read all the sequels and most of the prequels to Ender’s Game, and they were wonderful. I read some of his other books. I planned to read everything the man ever wrote. I was enamored. I planned the Ender’s Game movie in my head and I wanted to write books just as well as him someday.
Now, I was aware that OSC had a very strict religious and conservative background, which is just fine with me. Even when I disagreed with him on some of his points, he expressed them in such and elegant and un-condecending manner that impressed me. He never made you feel like your point of view was wrong, just that there were other options out there. But his main ideas were always those of inclusiveness, of peace, of love for everyone and, whether you grew up Mormon like Card or discovered you were a socialist through an online test like me, that’s something everyone can agree with and feel good about.
So it was with great sadness that I once ran across this article online, composed by Card. It is called “The Hypocrites of Homosexuality.” The gist of the article stem’s from Card’s belief that there is no scientific explanation for gay behavior, and that gay activities not only threaten the Christian world (“…one cannot serve two masters,” he writes), but the future of humanity itself. According to Card, when the gay lifestyle is accepted by society at large, less people will have children, and before you know it mankind will cease to exist. Let me know, if anyone cared to read it, if I got any of this wrong. Because I read it several times, trying to see what Card was really getting at, if there was actually some sense to his argument, if he was simply giving another point of view in his usually tactful way.
But I came away with nothing except what I summarized above. Now, I certainly understand where he is coming from with the religious thing, because it is something I have seen all my life. And by saying I understand, I in no way mean that I agree or even accept his line of reasoning. But I know what he’s talking about. The second part, all that downfall of society stuff, is really too ludicrous to even get upset over. Last time I checked, the straights outweighed the gays by a pretty substantial margin. And the gays have been around as long as humans have, and we’re still here, right? Even if being gay were ever accepted by society at large, thus giving more people the courage to come out and be who they are, I really don’t think not having enough babies will be an issue. That’s what China is for.
This article obviously soured me on OSC for a while, but I didn’t really think about it. I resolved that maybe I didn’t need to read all his books, but I would still value the ones that I had read. The themes of Ender’s Game still apply, regardless of who wrote it. But when I tried to read it again, maybe a year ago, I couldn’t do it. I could not separate the man from the art in my mind. How could anyone who wrote an article linking gays to the end of humanity possibly write Ender’s Game? It was still a beautiful book to me and I figured that, with time, I would be able to read it again. I’ve even recommended it to people since then.
Orson Scott Card has written a new article, published in the Mormon Times. According to Card, the recent passing of gay marriage laws in California and Massachusetts have rendered democracy invalid. People did not want these laws to be passed, and the courts passed them anyway. As such, people who truly believe in marriage should over throw the government, because they are creating an unfit environment to raise children or to foster democracy. Again, paraphrasing Card here. Let me know if I got something wrong.
I could go through the article line by line and offer a rebuttal, but I won’t and I can’t. It depresses me too much. I think even some of the most hard-core social conservatives would roll their eyes at some of Card’s claims. I mean, here’s an actual line from the article: “How long before married people answer the dictators thus: Regardless of law, marriage has only one definition, and any government that attempts to change it is my mortal enemy. I will act to destroy that government and bring it down, so it can be replaced with a government that will respect and support marriage, and help me raise my children in a society where they will expect to marry in their turn.” I mean, I don’t want to call him crazy because that would put me on somewhat of a level as him, but honestly. Read that again.
Like I said, I really don’t have to go line by line and explain everything that is faulty with some of his logic. And I’m not even going to touch the part where he starts comparing marriage and property laws because, A) that argument is a little creepy, B) it makes even less sense than some of my tangents (and that’s saying something), and C) I really don’t know what it’s supposed to fucking prove.
But the reason I brought any of this up in the first place is this: enough is enough. Whatever you think on any of these issues, whatever you believe God wants or society wants or whatever, this is downright hateful. This is a New York Times bestselling author saying this, and no one really brings it up. When congressmen say stuff like this, it’s forgotten with a smile and a shrug. And as much as I hate to compare gay rights to civil rights, which has many similarities and many, many differences, what if he had said this about another race? Or another religion? Why is it only okay when it is about the gays? Here’s a link to a rebuttal that can sum this stuff up better than I can. I just wanted to put my personal two cents in.
I’m done with Orson Scott Card. I’m done with Ender’s Game. And I’m done giving a pass to people who say stuff like this. Gays aren’t going to destroy society. Attitudes like this are. Whether you are straight, gay, Mormon, Methodist, Jedi, red state, blue state, whatever: we shouldn’t let this go any more. Because we’re all human. I feel stupid that I actually have to type that out, it sounds so trite, but people forget.
In the meantime, I’m looking for a new favorite book. Any suggestions? And I haven’t proofread this because I want to go to bed.




